Struggling with scrolling on my phone

Last week I saw dried dates on sale for 11 shekels a kilo, which is a great price. I bought 20 kilos with the intention to can them, since they are then easily blended and used as a sweetener for desserts.

However, my daughter gave birth this week and I was away for a few days, so the cases of dates were still waiting for me when I got back. When I looked this morning at what felt like a mountain of dates that needed to be pitted, checked for infestation, and then canned – and in a few days it will be Rosh Hashana and there’s already so many other things to do – I wondered why I had to create extra work for myself.

Then I began working on them while chatting with my husband before he started work, and I got through half of a 5 kg box. It would be easy to say, “I just spent so much time and I’ve only done 1/8 of the dates – how am I ever going to finish them all?”

But that’s not what I thought. As I packed the liter jars full and prepared them for canning, I genuinely appreciated all that I had done.

———————–

I’ve been doing a deeper level of decluttering in the last few months, as I go through things in my home and ask myself, “Does this have value to me right now?”

Moving things that I’m not using out of my home has been very positive. My house is getting easier and easier to clean, and I can maintain it with much less effort. And it makes me more relaxed and accomplished.

Every little bit I’ve done has been so gratifying and as I celebrate it, it encourages me to do more.

——————-

I’ve really been grappling with my phone use. I’ve felt shame that I scroll as much as I do, that I don’t control myself and use my time better. Coming to understand just how intentionally human emotion and addiction psychology has been studied with the intent to create addiction has lessened that shame somewhat, as I realize my struggle is shared by most people.

But I still have great frustration over the effort to minimize my screen use.

For those who are wondering about our family technology stance: our children don’t use internet, though occasionally when I need to go out or do something when my husband is working, he’ll let the younger kids (ages 8, 8, 8) sit next to him in his home office and watch something like Mister Rogers. We don’t have Ipads and they don’t play computer games.

When we drive places, they listen to music on the car speakers and look out the window or look at books.

Of our three teenage boys (16, 18 and 19), the two who are living in dorms have chosen not to have any kind of phone at all. The youngest has regular daily learning sessions on the phone, so he has a simple ‘dumb’ phone that he uses at home but doesn’t take with him during the day. He does take it with him when he travels.

Sounds great, right? I’m very glad my children are growing up in the real world, with real people, real experiences, and plenty of outdoor time. It’s really important to me.

The challenge is for me and my husband, and I always think of us as the weak links in our home technology use. (My husband got rid of his smartphone a couple of years ago, but works online.)

I got off of Facebook five years ago, even though it meant closing my business page and that was significant. The only social media platform I use is YouTube. While I don’t ever actively contribute or engage on YouTube, and the content I watch/listen to is overall positive, it is driven by an algorithm that targets exactly what interests each person, and that is what keeps me looking longer than I intend to.

I’ve tried putting boundaries around my phone use: don’t look at it until after a certain time of day, be conscious of keeping it in a room where I’m not at. I took our family picture off of the screensaver months ago so it would be visually unstimulating. A couple of months ago I began calling a phone line for Torah classes to listen to higher quality content that doesn’t arrive through the internet, to partially replace the podcasts I listened to on YouTube.

But I still feel frustrated with not being able to completely subdue the phone issue. It’s something that always has to be managed. I slide away from my good intentions, and then have to restart again.

Sometimes I am weary of feeling unsuccessful about my efforts in this area.

This morning, at my request, my husband loaded a black screen onto my phone to use as wallpaper, so there’s not only not a family picture, but there’s no appealing color or design on my screen. This is recommended as a step to minimizing phone usage, and I was glad to have it done.

At that moment, I thought, ‘Why am I not appreciating all the things I’ve done in this area, and keep focusing on what isn’t yet the way I want? This is a good step!”

I have 17.5 kilos of dates waiting to be checked and processed, and that may have to wait for another week to finish, but I didn’t focus on that – I felt accomplished with the dates I did.

I’m not finished decluttering every single corner of my home, but I’ve mentally cheered for single thing I moved out of the house. Cumulatively all of these things have led to a bigger impact felt by everyone in the home.

For today, I’m reminding myself that positive change only happens by appreciating the small steps, and continuing to make steps in the direction you want to go. I want to minimize digital clutter in my life (I’m wishful about eliminating it completely), but that’s an ongoing process.

I don’t love the struggle, but everything I’ve done to improve the situation has been constructive. When I appreciate those efforts, I can let myself be where I am right now, without criticizing myself for not yet being at the finish line.

Once again, I’m reminded of the saying, “By the inch it’s a cinch; by the mile it’s a trial.” I seem to have to continually remind myself to pause, look at what I’ve done, and say ‘good job, me!”

I’m going to hold on to this thought as I’m thinking about the things I want to improve in as the Jewish New Year approaches.

Can you relate? How do you manage your thoughts/feelings/actions around the things you wish you were doing differently?

Avivah

Comments

8 responses to “Struggling with scrolling on my phone”

  1. Rivka Avatar
    Rivka

    Thank you for sharing this important topic, Avivah!
    I would like to ask you a question which I’m sure is relevant for your readers.
    The world appears to be going further in the direction of social media and smartphones (and beyond). Our children may have to deal with people with chips installed in their heads.
    In terms of their chinuch, how do we teach them to be in control of themselves when it comes to technology? How can we do that if we’re effectively teaching them to stay away from technology?
    I honestly find it hard to believe that it will possible to abstain from modern technology for much longer.
    Thanks.

    1. Avivah Avatar
      Avivah

      This is a huge topic, Rivka, as you know!

      For now I’ll just say that I don’t teach my kids to stay away from technology – my older children have chosen to do that themselves.They see how people walk around zoned out and unfocused, not acknowledging one another. I talk a lot to them about my perspective and my struggle with tech, and they also see the steps I take to keep it in check. One day they’ll need to use technology, but my hope is they will be mindful and intentional.

  2. T.L. Avatar
    T.L.

    Thanks again for addressing this topic – it really helps me navigate the daily struggles of life. What truly helps me is actually learning from you how to balance striving for a lot with accepting reality.

    Today, I found myself sweeping the floor in frustration, thinking that this nice clean floor wouldn’t last long. Then I had a small insight: what is being swept now is gone for good. Sure, more will appear soon, but this exact mess is gone forever – these crumbs will never return.

    1. Avivah Avatar
      Avivah

      TL – when you’re sweeping, don’t forget to enjoy how nice your floor is to look at in that moment! Sometimes I’ve felt a bit despairing of how much I clean and what a short time it stays nice, but you know what? I know it was clean, and my family knows it was clean, and it felt good to everyone. So clean stays our baseline, even though often it gets messy.

  3. Shira Avatar
    Shira

    You and everyone else….
    Personally I don’t have a smartphone because I know I would get hopelessly addicted. I waste plenty enough time on the computer, but at least that’s easier to just turn off and put away. I also find that for me, having a filter and using it to limit the hours when I have internet access is critical.

    1. Avivah Avatar
      Avivah

      I resisted getting a smartphone for SO many years for exactly this reason. My husband would periodically tell me it would make my life easier to have one, and I said, I don’t care, I know these things are addictive and I don’t want to start with it. It’s true that you can waste plenty of time on a computer but as you said, at least you can’t carry it with you wherever you go!

      I like your suggestions about limiting the hours when you have internet access.

  4. Chaya+Dina Avatar
    Chaya+Dina

    I definitely relate! I do not use a smart phone, and my dumb phone does not even have texting. But both of the jobs I work are online using my laptop, and for one of my jobs I am required to have WhatsAPP. I installed it on my computer. That way, I only have to open up my son’s old phone once per month to keep it active. I asked a shelia about this and also about using WA with my grown children and was given the ok. I HATE WA for work. It is SO distracting and it makes me anxious. I have put limits on my WA use in that I do not use it for anything/anyone other than my children and work. I simply tell other people that I do not use WA. It means a lot of inconvenience for me in terms of contacting businesses, administrative offices, etc., but I am very strong on this because I see how distracting and anxiety-producing it is for me just in relation to my work.
    It is very helpful to have a laptop that can be taken out when I start to work and PUT AWAY at the end of the day.
    My feeling is that the longer children and young adults can avoid all technology, the better. Give their brains a chance to mature fully and they are less likely to fall into technology addiction. Of course, they also need to be taught how the science of persuasive design is used to addict children and adults to their devices. There is NOTHING benign about this. I just listened to a series of interviews with Richard Freed, who wrote “Better Than Real Life,” on this topic, and I really encourage everyone to educate themselves and their children on this topic.

  5. NS Avatar
    NS

    I don’t carry a smart phone but, even so, my Youtube habit on my laptop was getting out of control at one point. I was watching informative and interesting videos on a range of topics that interest me but it was making me feel like garbage.
    It helped me a lot to substitute it with clips from Torah Anytime. I found a few speakers who have short videos that are informative and entertaining. We’re not talking about deep Torah – just short and fun and a bit thought provoking. Then whenever I had the Youtube craving, it wasn’t hard to talk my yetzer hara into trying one of my favorite speakers on Torah Anytime. And after I while the habit of opening Youtube unthinkingly faded. (I still am careful to avoid it – as I have to use it for work sometimes. I just go there, grab links and run!)
    I have a become a regular donor to Torah Anytime as I feel they helped me break a habit that was just making me feel so gross BH!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *