Dd and concussion

Yesterday was ds12’s birthday, so we enjoy a nice birthday dinner and then a special home movie.  Everyone got to sleep late, but somehow, I woke up much earlier than usual today!  I love the idea of going to sleep early and getting up early, but it doesn’t seem to work well for me at this stage of life.  So even though my early rising was prompted by concern I was feeling about dd16, I appreciated being able to have an early morning today.

On Thursday night my dd16 slipped, fell down five steps, and her head slammed into the wall.  It was a serious fall, though she didn’t pass out, and was loud enough that it brought people running from all over who heard. It was, as she put it, one of the scariest things that ever happened to her, and her friend who was with her said the same thing, that just seeing it was incredibly scary. 

As soon as I learned about this (she mentioned it on her blog), I was concerned that she had suffered a concussion, even though she insisted she was fine when I called her.  (She always plays down any pain or discomfort she has.)  I told her I wanted her to get arnica and start taking it every few hours, and find an osteopath who could do cranio-sacral work to deal with the blow to her head.  She agreed to find out about where to buy arnica and to look for an osteopath but I could tell it was because I said so, not because she was concerned. 

Yesterday morning I was surprised by an early morning call, letting me know she was on her way to the doctor since she was having so a lot of nausea and bad headaches.   Knowing how much she dislikes doctors and her tendency to tell me everything is fine, it was obvious she was worried about her symptoms, which in an of itself concerned me.  By this time, I was absolutely positive that she had a concussion, and though I didn’t have much confidence in this doctor, because I’d already heard that the feedback from students who have been there a couple of years is that the diagnostic ability/competence isn’t very high, I told dd that at least it would be valuable for assessment purposes.

When I called her back later in the day to find out how the visit was, she told me the doctor said she couldn’t have a concussion since she wasn’t vomiting, and that her symptoms were from stress.  Right.  She was perfectly healthy two days before but she got so stressed out over her relaxing and enjoyable Shabbos with friends that she starts having intense head pain and nausea, and there’s absolutely no connection to a major blow to the head the day before her symptoms began- makes perfect sense, doesn’t it?!?  This isn’t the kind of thing that instills confidence in the medical profession. 

Dd16 realized based on the reading she did about this before going that it wasn’t accurate, but the other girls in her program accepted the stress diagnosis, even though all of them are skeptical about this doctor.  Dd couldn’t understand how they were willing to accept feedback that made no sense, especially since they know her and that she’s not a person to make things up, and they know that the doctor doesn’t have a reputation for being competent.  (If you’re wondering why she went, it’s because this is the doctor the school sends the girls to.)   She found the unquestioning confidence in medical authority somewhat disturbing. 

I think it was harder for her to feel invalidated than to experience the pain and discomfort she was having, to have what she was feeling to be minimized since it must just be ‘stress’.  I said to dd that it must be hard to be in a situation where there’s not much understanding or validation for the physical symptoms she was having.  And she said, “Yes, but I’m lucky I have a mother like you to talk to.”  I really love her!  And I feel pretty lucky myself to have such a wonderful daughter.

Thank G-d we’re not dependent on this doctor to be her primary care physician, and I’m very, very grateful that her dorm counselor has an interest in alternative health so she is a great resource person for dd.  Otherwise I don’t know where she’d start trying to get the information and help that she really needs.  Her counselor even offered to lend her money for the visit to the osteopath.  I’m also grateful that we know about options to the ‘let her suffer and wait it out’ approach, and have the resources to pay for this, since private doctors are outside of the coverage of the school insurance plan. 

I was glad to speak to her early today and hear she has an appointment this Thursday with an osteopath.  She’ll have to take the day off from school to travel over 2.5 hours in each direction to get there, but the main thing is that she has an appointment!  And she was glad to tell me that a friend called her grandmother, a doctor here in the US, and told her what the doctor dd had gone to said, and the grandmother doctor said it was inaccuate information and it definitely sounds like a concussion.  Now another friend of hers in the school is planning to call her parent who is a doctor about dd, and dd is feeling better just knowing that someone else in her school knows that it’s not all in her head!  (Or should I say, that it literally is all in her head? :P)

Even though dd didn’t have a stress component regarding her concussion, I did :), and I’m also feeling much better knowing that she’ll be seeing someone who has the possibility of offering her concrete help. 

Avivah

8 thoughts on “Dd and concussion

  1. I would have major issues with a school that does not provide care for a student that fell down stairs and hit her head. She wasn’t vomiting so she couldn’t have a concussion? Amazing. I’m glad someone there is helping her to follow up, but she should have been seen by someone competent much sooner.

  2. iy’H she should have a refuah shleima and you should hear only good news!! I really hope she is feeling better. Sending good thoughts and prayers your way.

    1. Elizabeth, the school sent her to the town doctor and they accept what the doctor said, so they feel this has been taken care of. The school nurse told her the pain and nausea she’s been having is all in her head (based soley on what the doctor said, the nurse didn’t check her or ask her anything). It’s frustrating to me but I understand that I have a different idea of how to respond to a concussion, and they aren’t willing to consider that the doctor might not have diagnosed her correctly.

      As far as the dorm counselor (married woman, btw) helping her, I meant that she knows about alot of alternatives that most people wouldn’t be aware of that are in line with my approach to health. I don’t expect the administration to know about non-standard ways to handle health issues, so I accept that as my responsibility.

      R – thank you! I hope so, too.

  3. hi Avivah- I hope your daughter is doing better. It sounds like 2.5 hours is quite a schlep to get to an osteopath esp with a suspected concussion. Here is a listing of 2 osteopaths in Haifa. It may be worthwhile to contact them just to see. And for what it’s worth. Dr. Waldman is already based at Rambam so if there is further follow up required she will be onsite. Thursday is too long to wait I believe for any kind of head injury. Refuah Sheleima!

    WALDMAN Mervyn
    (General Osteopathic Council registered)
    Pain Relief Unit,
    Rambam Hospital,
    Phone: 04 854 2880

    36, Blitenthal Street,
    Ramat Almogi
    Cellphone: 0545 935 862
    Email: mw120@netvision.net.il

    1. Ja-el, thank you very much for your recommendations. I’m going to do some research based on the info you’ve provided me with, to see if for future visits or follow-up care she can find someone closer.

      Thanks, Chava! (Btw, we may both have a chance to meet you in person since we’re hoping to come to the zoo meet-up at the beginning of Feb, and someone told me that you’re one of those who attends.:))

  4. I hope your dd is feeling better. I don’t know where your dd is in Israel but my brother is an MD, family practitioner in J-m. While he is a regular conventional dr. he is a good dr. ( not just co’s he’s my brother :)) he is well known & liked in J-m. LMK if you need his phone #

  5. Stuck on symptoms is no good. Glad that wasn’t the doctor I took my dd 12 to when her appendix burst this past summer. “no fever, no vomiting? Nope, can’t be her appendix!” except of course it was. Even our good doc said “I’m not sure. 50/50 chance. Better take her to the ER for an ultrasound to be sure”

    Refuah shleimah wishes to your daughter.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

WP-SpamFree by Pole Position Marketing