You can’t make everyone happy, but you can create boundaries for yourself

The hosting of the Shabbos sheva brachos has ended and it went so beautifully. There was a lot of uncertainty for an extended period about where we would have the meals. I made a point to trust it would all work out rather than get anxious, and thankfully it did – it wasn’t until Tuesday evening that we found the venue that we would be using for Friday/Saturday. It was exactly what I wanted. Since it was recently renovated and wasn’t suitable for our needs prior to the renovation, no one had thought of it as an option when I was asking around.

We hosted our mothers, all of our married children and our newest son-in-law’s parents, siblings and their families. Being two large families with a lot of young families, it was a lot of people to host for sleeping and meals, but we were so happy to have everyone. It was a beautiful Shabbos with two families who were able to genuinely enjoy getting to know one another.

I self-catered three meals for approximately 45 people at each meal (my oldest daughter prepared all the desserts). As much as I very much wanted to, I wasn’t able to find people to hire to do the setting up and serving, so our children stepped in for that. They were great. But it was a lot of work that I would have preferred we didn’t have to do.

I felt good about having all the sleeping arrangements taken care of, having plenty of food well organized, and being calm and present for all the different relationships in the midst of such a busy time of doing. There were changes and disappointments and things that didn’t go as planned, and I stayed relaxed and rolled with the punches. I was extending myself for a lot of people and glad to be able to do it, and didn’t feel pressured or stressed.

It was on Saturday night that I got some feedback that was unfair and judgmental. It was certainly unwelcome and inappropriate at that moment in time, after an extended period of so much giving.

When I finally was able to get to bed, I was deeply exhausted. After a few hours of sleep, I woke up to do some journaling, which I haven’t done for some time. I wrote and wrote and wrote. Pages. About all the things I did, and how well I did them and how good I felt about it.

I wrote about the critical comments and how unkind and unjustified it felt. Usually I try to think about things from the other person’s perspective and understand them, but in my journal I allowed myself to have my own feelings of hurt and anger about it.

What came out for me of all this writing, was the very clear realization that it’s just not possible to make everyone happy all the time, no matter how hard I try and no matter how well everything goes. Everyone isn’t going to appreciate my efforts, appreciate me, and think I’m a good enough person. Everyone isn’t going to feel that I give them what they need.

The larger our family grows, the more the expectations of me grow. There are more and more people who come into the family, through marriage or birth, with their own ideas of who and how I should be. I’m no longer ‘just’ a wife, mother and daughter, but a mother-in-law and grandmother. Those who married in to our family grew up in a different family environment with different ideas of what my role in their lives should look like. Even with our biological children, there are different levels of satisfaction with how I parent. Everyone has expectations of how I should be, what I should do, what I should give (in terms of energy, time and physical resources). And I can’t adequately meet some of those expectations.

Obviously, making everyone happy or wanting to be appreciated by everyone for your efforts can’t be the goal, because it’s unobtainable.

I mentioned to a mother with several adult married children a few weeks ago that a married child/spouse was disgruntled with something I hadn’t done in the way they wanted, and she looked at me without saying anything for a long moment. I told her, “Don’t tell me you’ve never experienced this!” She responded, “That’s how it always is; I take it as the norm.”

There’s so much written about the challenges of growing children and busy households, but much less shared about the challenges and realities of this stage of life. After decades of parenting and homemaking, rather than slowing down and taking it easy, a mother is expected to up the bar and do more and more and more, for more and more people. She is expected to be calm, organized, giving, nurturing and patient, and magically know how to meet each person’s needs in the way they prefer.

I went directly from this demanding wedding period into Purim and organizing all of the necessary activities, and will soon begin Pesach preparations. We’ll be having my mom and three married children staying with us; my daughter will host another of our married children for sleeping. All five families will be with us for the seder and four families for the ensuing meals for as long as each chooses to stay.

I love having everyone together, seeing the grandchildren playing together and all the adults spending time together gives me much nachas. I have non-ending gratitude for all of the wonderful people who have joined our family and each adds so much.

Does that sound warm and fuzzy and oh, so beautiful? All the amazing family togetherness, with everyone getting along?

It’s very special and I never take it for granted.

And it’s a huge amount of work.

I’m now taking some quiet time for myself to regroup. I’m assessing how much I can give and how much I want to give, regardless of what others want of me. There are things I’ve willingly stretched myself to do, and after the minimal or nonexistent recognition of those efforts, am choosing to stop stretching rather than become resentful. These adjustments aren’t likely to be welcomed by those who are used to being on the receiving end but they need to be made.

It’s a good thing to be concerned about the comfort and happiness of others. But it’s not a good thing to do so much that you compromise yourself and your own happiness. There’s no one at fault if you’re overextended and unappreciated. You’re the one who needs to create boundaries that protect yourself, you’re the one who has to take care of yourself, and by doing that, you teach others how to treat you.

Avivah

7 thoughts on “You can’t make everyone happy, but you can create boundaries for yourself

  1. What an important perspective about life, and I value the true voice of yours, and the ability to enjoy the happy parts of life despite the uncomfortable ones at the same time. So many of us would automatically feel like everything’s bad and rough, while you manage to handle all emotions and feelings at the same time, which is very, very special.

    1. Thank you, Tehilla. I find that when I keep my focus on the many, many things that I’m blessed with, life feels quite good! I don’t expect that everything has to be perfect to enjoy all the blessings I have.

      I hesitated about writing this post, because on one hand, I want to share authentically because this is part of this stage. On the other hand, I don’t want to seem as if I’m venting, because that’s not my intent. I have the ability to process negative experiences without sharing them here, but I think there’s value in sharing different aspects of a stage of life.

  2. Avivah, I so connected to your writing and feelings. Bh’ also have married children, (not as many as you) and I know they really appreciate what I do for the families, Shabbatot, Chaggim. I did make a couple rules the past year. I can’t have the parents, and my grandkids here all at once. For me its too hard, overwhelming. We have each couple with their children and we get together when there is a birthday, or other Chaggim we can meet at a park. I am getting older and I can’t handle the noise level anymore. I try to sit with my grandkids and play, read to them, and have fun. If I am not feeling well, (unfortunately the past year has been like that) I tell them I need to rest a bit. I am always happy when the adult parents can take a break, but I see I have my limits also. I am learning to be more open, and our adult children are also learning how to deal with my limitations.

    1. Hi! Long time reader, haven’t commented in a while! So beautiful to watch the family grow! These are normal growing pains! Definitely sounds like some adjustments are needed and you may be pleasantly surprised to see others step up to the plate, like how your oldest daughter took care of desserts! Or they may have to be more self sufficient. Some of that comes from the privilege of being part of a large family.
      The best mother/mother-in-law/safta is a happy, smiling, laughing one! Keep smiling! You’re doing great!

    2. Thank you for sharing this, Rachelli. It’s nice to know someone who is in the same stage of life understands just what I’m writing about!

      For three years prior to August 2022, my energy was very impacted by the car accident I was in. I don’t like to complain and though I referenced it from time to time, have realized that it wasn’t apparent how much more limited I was as a result. When you’re not feeling well, it really makes a huge difference.

      My first daugher-in-law’s mother told me, you’re going to reach a point that you just don’t want to have everyone together all at once because it’s so much noise. I didn’t yet have experience to understand that, but now I do. I hope I can continue to have as many of our children together at once for as long as they want to come, but there’s no question that it takes energy being around so many people for an extended period.

  3. Hi Avivah,

    Creating boundaries instead of letting resentment build is so wise.

    I also wonder if it would be good to communicate your limitations and boundary choices to family members so they know ahead of time how things will be different, and hopefully others will offer to fill in the areas where you’re stepping back?

    Kelly

    1. I spoke to all of our adult kids prior to writing this post, to let them know about the one big change I’m making. I definitely wouldn’t want to spring it out of the blue on them.

      So far my experience is that when I’m clear about my boundaries, that I’m able to respectfully communicate that and have it be received pretty well.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

WP-SpamFree by Pole Position Marketing